Water Research Simulation in Unreal and Maya - Summary and Conclusions

On this entry I'll try to summarize my experience with different water simulations techniques to date. Note that this is the result of a student's research only so please put big quotes on everything I'm saying.
The techniques researched can be divided into two sections depending on the subject:
-        Simulation of the water planes, for “static” waters.
-        Simulation of “dynamic” water, for water splash effects.

Also they can be divided depending on the technology:
-        Maya
-        Unreal Engine

The most relevant techniques for the Animation Project were:
-        Unreal Engine’s Starter Pack Water materials, for water planes.
-        Maya’s Bifrost simulation combined with Mesh conversion and Alembic Cache export, that is imported as Geometry Cache in Unreal, for the water splash.

The summary of techniques researched are as follows:
Name
Type
Technology
Comments
Maya Ocean Shader
Water Plane
Maya
Nice easy approach.
Didn't try to export to Unreal Engine.
Octoplug Ocean Shader
Water Plane
Maya
Good results but complex application through Node Editor and very limited online documentation. At least for a novice like me, more suited for somebdoy with experience.
Didn't try to export to Unreal Engine.
Bifrost Simulations
Water Splash
Maya
Particles dynamic simulation.
Great posibilities.
Possible approach to export to Unreal: convert to Mesh and export as alembic. Then import it into UE as Geometry Cache.
Unreal Engine Starter Pack Materials
Water Planes
Unreal
Nice easy out of the box materials.
Need a bit of adaptation when changed the default geometry.
Unreal Engine Gestner Waves
Water Planes
Unreal
Mathematical Approach to simulate the waves on a water plane by the use of sin and cosine functions. Looks very powerful, although complex to implement, I didn’t finish the research on them.

Final Output: different recordings were done in Unreal Engine. All of them were done setting up a Bifrost simulation in Maya, exporting to alembic as a mesh, and importing into UE as Geometry Cache.







Comentarios

Publicar un comentario

Entradas populares de este blog

The Solution: Alembic Cache

Imagen
ALEMBIC CACHE INTRO Today I'll show the complete workflow for simulating the splash of water in Maya using Bifrost and then importing it into Unreal Engine. On the last episode our hero was left in a sea of doubts, wondering if he'd have to abandon the idea of simulating the water in Bifrost and start a singing career instead. Well, either that or finding a new approach for the water simulation. Actually I researched a few options to do the water splash simulation in Maya and found a few some interesting options. The most promising and similar in approach to Bifrost (use of particles) looked like NVIDIA Flex. I however didn't follow that path. I leave some links on the bottom if you want to explore it. Doing a short recap, I was stuck on how to export the simulation done in Bifrost to Unreal. The solution came from an option in the Bifrost Fluid simulation to convert the simulation into a mesh and using an export called Allembic Mesh. Thanks Michael Connolly for ...
Leer más

Objectives - 3D Water Animation

Imagen
3D Water Simulation for animation Through exploring and contrasting different options on water simulation that can be applied to an animation project done in Unreal or Maya. The objective would be to find a technique that suits to the animation project, but also build knowledge for future projects. Intro: personal interest on water simulation I've always had certain fascination on the  power of water to transmit emotions: water can transmit calm and introspection but can also show action, threat, epic and fury, transmitted through the power of the waves and foam. Or mystery of the creatures and secrets that are hidden underneath it. Calm waters in Samil (Vigo, Spain) Turbulent waters in Howth (Dublin, Ireland) I tend to pay attention at the way water and waves are portrayed on paintings and comics. Each artist has a different view of how to express the emotion that the water transmits. For example below we can see the difference between Hugo Pratt's s...
Leer más